Do antihistamines prevent biphasic allergic reactions?
Date First Published:
July 12, 2013
Last Updated:
July 12, 2013
Report by:
Jennifer Lewis , 4th Year Medical Student (Manchester Royal Infirmary )
Three-Part Question:
In [children after an allergic reaction] do [antihistamines] prevent [biphasic reactions]?
Clinical Scenario:
A 14 girl presents to Paediatric A&E with her mother with a widespread urticarial rash and swollen lips after eating some egg to which she is allergic. You administer antihistamines and her symptoms improve. You prescribe antihistamines for discharge and wonder if they will prevent a biphasic reaction?
Search Strategy:
Medline 1946 to June Week 1 2013
EMBASE 1980 to 2013 Week 26
EMBASE 1980 to 2013 Week 26
Search Details:
‘((exp hypersensitivity/) OR (exp anaphylaxis/) OR (anaphyla$.mp) OR (aller$.mp) OR (acute ADJ allergic ADJ reaction)) AND ((biphasic.mp) OR (exp recurrence/) OR (early ADJ phase ADJ reaction) OR (late ADJ phase ADJ reaction) OR (delayed ADJ reaction)) AND ((exp Histamine H1 antagonists/) OR (exp Chlorphenamine/) OR (exp cetirizine/) OR (antihistamin$.mp) OR (hayfever medication.mp)) LIMITS – Humans, English Language, Children aged 0 – 18.
Cochrane Library; Title, Abstract, Keywords (antihistamine) and Title, Abstract, Keywords (allergy) and Title, Abstract, Keywords (biphasic)
Outcome:
3 relevant papers, of which one is a Cochrane Review
Relevant Paper(s):
| Study Title | Patient Group | Study type (level of evidence) | Outcomes | Key results | Study Weaknesses |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| H1-antihistamines for the treatment of anaphylaxis with and without shock Sheikh, A., ten Broek, V., Brown, S. G. & Simons, F. E. 2010 Scotland | All eligible papers including patients experiencing anaphylaxis caused by food, insect venom, medication, anaesthetics, latex or exercise | Systematic Review | Clinical improvement anaphylaxis by antihistamines | There were no high quality randomised or quasi-randomised controlled trials comparing antihistamines with placebo or no intervention. | Only considers antihistamine effect on anaphylaxis and not mild allergic reactions |
| Cetirizine inhibits skin reactions but not mediator release in immediate and developing late-phase allergic cutaneous reactions. A double-blind, placebo-controlled study Nielsen PN, Skov PS, Poulsen LK, Schmelz M, Petersen LJ. 2000 Denmark | Ten subjects, all allergic to grass pollen on no antihistamine medication | Single centre randomised, double blind, placebo controlled, cross over trial. | Skin reactions to intradermal histamine and grass pollen injections | Weal reactions to histamine and grass pollen were significantly reduced by cetirizine (Placebo 2663±238mm2 vs. cetirizine 1934±370mm2) | Small sample size |
| Allergic reaction mediator levels in the blood | Histamine and tryptase levels in the blood after allergen exposure were not altered by cetirizine | ||||
| Multiphasic anaphylaxis: an uncommon event in the emergency department. Brady WJ, Luber S, Carter CT, Guertler A, Lindbeck G. 2008 USA | 1261 allergic reaction patients. | Retrospective chart review of out of hospital, ED and hospital records over a 4.5 year period | Rate of biphasic reactions | 67 anaphylactic reactions of which 2 (3%) were biphasic | Only analysis of biphasic anaphylactic reactions rather than mild reactions included. |
| Antihistamine use in biphasic reactions | Both cases received on-going antihistamine use after discharge for first reaction then returning 26 and 40 hours later with urticaria |
Author Commentary:
From the literature available the use of antihistamines for allergic reaction is commonplace. However there is a lack of high quality evidence to support their use in anaphylaxis as demonstrated by the Cochrane review.
Nielsen et al conducted a randomised double-blind trial to illicit the effects of cetirizine on histamine levels and reactions in the body, they deduced that cetirizine did help to reduce the size and number of wheals found on the skin after intradermal injection of grass pollen and of histamine but it has no effect on histamine levels in the blood. They conclude histamine is not one of the key mediators in late phase reactions, suggesting that antihistamine medication will not be able to prevent biphasic or late phase reactions. Although considering only anaphylactic biphasic reactions, Brady et al encountered only 2 patients, of who both were on antihistamines at the time of their biphasic reactions.
Nielsen et al conducted a randomised double-blind trial to illicit the effects of cetirizine on histamine levels and reactions in the body, they deduced that cetirizine did help to reduce the size and number of wheals found on the skin after intradermal injection of grass pollen and of histamine but it has no effect on histamine levels in the blood. They conclude histamine is not one of the key mediators in late phase reactions, suggesting that antihistamine medication will not be able to prevent biphasic or late phase reactions. Although considering only anaphylactic biphasic reactions, Brady et al encountered only 2 patients, of who both were on antihistamines at the time of their biphasic reactions.
Bottom Line:
More research is needed in this area, there is currently no evidence to suggest antihistamines reduce the occurrence of biphasic reactions therefore they should still be prescribed on discharge until more evidence is available.
References:
- Sheikh, A., ten Broek, V., Brown, S. G. & Simons, F. E.. H1-antihistamines for the treatment of anaphylaxis with and without shock
- Nielsen PN, Skov PS, Poulsen LK, Schmelz M, Petersen LJ.. Cetirizine inhibits skin reactions but not mediator release in immediate and developing late-phase allergic cutaneous reactions. A double-blind, placebo-controlled study
- Brady WJ, Luber S, Carter CT, Guertler A, Lindbeck G.. Multiphasic anaphylaxis: an uncommon event in the emergency department.